| |
CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF VIENNA |
|
| |
PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES |
|
| |
JULY 22, 2002 |
|
| |
|
|
| |
Chairperson Curtis opened the meeting at 6:00pm, and led the Pledge of
Allegiance |
|
| |
to the flag. |
|
| |
|
Present: |
Vernon Curtis, Ben Ranger, Scott Preseau, Gery Giltinan, Lee Garner, Dale |
|
| |
Frappier, Robert Palmer, and Mary Johnson. |
|
| |
|
Absent: |
Max Schweitzer. |
|
| |
|
|
Minutes: |
Motion by Frappier, seconded by Ranger to approve the minutes of July 8, 02 |
|
| |
as presented. All ayes. Motion carries. |
|
| |
|
Additions/ |
|
|
Changes: |
Chairperson Curtis added Dan Mills to Petitions. In 1994 a pond permit was |
|
| |
pulled for his property by a different owner and he would like to use that
permit to |
|
| |
construct a pond without going through the entire process. |
|
| |
|
Communications: |
1.Packet from Tony McKerchie from the Michigan Railroads
Association concerning |
|
| |
set backs for development along railroad rights-of-way. |
|
| |
2. Draft of new Master Plan from Vilican-Leman. |
|
| |
|
Petitions: |
1. Public Hearing, Paul Merritt for Elizabeth's Assisted
Living. |
|
| |
|
| |
Mr. Merritt spoke to the Board and audience and explained that he wanted to |
|
| |
increase the capacity of his adult foster care to 20 from 13. He presented
plans for |
|
| |
the addition. |
|
| |
| |
Audience Comments: |
|
| |
Vicki Price, 1403 W. Vienna Rd. said the home has been a good neighbor and
she |
|
| |
had no problem with increasing the size, but has concerns that if Mr.
Merritt ever |
|
| |
sold could for instance a drug rehab/recovery place go in. |
|
| |
Chairperson Curtis said the Board would have to check into this. |
|
| |
| |
Herb Nelson, 1385 W. Vienna Rd. said that we all need an answer to Ms.
Price's |
|
| |
question before any vote. |
|
| |
| |
Audrey Howell, 1385 W. Vienna Rd. asked if more parking spaces would be
added |
|
| |
and what road it would come in off of. Mr. Merritt said yes to more parking
and also |
|
| |
addressed the issue of a dumpster. He said a dumpster would be hidden by
fencing |
|
| |
and that the new parking spaces might come off Water St. |
|
| |
| |
Bob Palmer said he needed approximately 10 more parking spaces, but these
issues |
| |
will be dealt with under Site Plan Review. |
|
| |
| |
Board Comments: |
|
| |
Preseau said he agrees with not wanting drug rehab and that the Board will
seek an |
|
| |
opinion from the State and our Attorney. |
|
| |
| |
Motion by Garner, seconded by Preseau to table this issue until August 12th
when |
|
| |
these questions can be answered. |
|
| |
Voting yes: Frappier, Preseau, Giltinan, Ranger, Garner, and Curtis |
|
| |
Voting no: None, motion carries. |
|
| |
| |
2. Special Land Use Permit for a pond. Kenneth &
Catherine Wheeler. |
|
| |
Mr Wheeler said the reason they wanted to construct a pond was to beautify
the |
|
| |
area and help with flooding problems. |
|
| |
| |
Audience Comments: |
|
| |
Catherine Wheeler said she thought it was a great idea. |
|
| |
| |
Board Comments: |
|
| |
Curtis asked what will be done with excess dirt, and Mr. Wheeler said it
would be |
|
| |
used for berms. |
|
| |
Palmer said he did have a serious problem with flooding and this would help
a great |
|
| |
deal. |
|
| |
| |
Motion by Preseau, seconded by Garner to grant the Special Land Use permit. |
|
| |
Voting yes: Preseau, Garner, Giltinan, Frappier, Curtis. |
|
| |
Voting no: none |
|
| |
Abstaining: Ranger, Catherine Wheeler is his sister. Motion carries. |
|
| |
| |
3. Set Public Hearing dates for Centennial Oaks.
|
|
| |
Secretary Garner read the Notice of Public hearing with publish dates of
July 24th |
|
| |
and August 7th, 2002 with a hearing date of August 12, 2002. Centennial Oaks |
|
| |
is requesting that the entire parcel be rezoned to RU-1 for the purpose of
building |
|
| |
site condominiums. |
|
| |
Motion by Garner, seconded by Preseau to set the public hearing date of
August |
|
| |
12, 2002. All ayes. Motion carries. |
|
| |
| |
4. Dan Mills, 1075 W. Lake Rd. is requesting he be
allowed to use a pond permit |
|
| |
issued in 1994 to the past owner, who never started construction, and that
his |
|
| |
construction would follow the previously approved plans. |
|
| |
Board comments: |
|
| |
Curtis said he would say no because ordinances have changed since 1994 and
this |
|
| |
would set a precedence. |
|
| |
Frappier said he knows the process is lengthy but setting a precedence would
not |
|
| |
be proper. |
|
| |
Garner said that a permit is for the person not the property. |
|
| |
Preseau said that the neighbors who were notified have probably changed. |
|
| |
Ranger said in 8 years a lot has changed. The consensus of the Board is that
Mr. |
|
| |
Mills could not use the permit issued in 1994. |
|
| |
|
Report of |
|
|
Committies: |
Report of Pond Committee was presented by Garner. |
|
| |
Committee consists of Ranger, Garner, and Palmer. Schweitzer was not
present. |
|
| |
Checked four ponds. |
|
| |
1. Christenson, Saginaw Rd. They are making progress and
the north end should be |
|
| |
completed by October 31, 2002. |
|
| |
2. Gardner, Neff Rd. the construction is very different
than the plan presented. He is |
|
| |
actually running an excavation business with no intention of putting in a
pond. It is a |
|
| |
mining operation. |
|
| |
3. Lammy, Frances Rd. there has not been much progress
made, and there is more |
|
| |
water. |
|
| |
4. Stark, Dodge Rd. This is a very nice pond and it has
been completed. |
|
| |
It was decided to request that Gardner and Lammy appear before the Board to |
|
| |
explain what they are doing. |
|
| |
Preseau would like the committee to check each pond site before they come to
the |
|
| |
Planning Commission. Ranger said the committee or the building inspector
could |
|
| |
check so the petitioner would not be held up if the committee was not
available. |
|
| |
|
|
|
New Business: |
Some discussion on packets presented to the Board Members and when they |
|
| |
actually need the entire packet because some members forget to bring the
packet |
|
| |
to the next meeting. Most petitioners that come to the Planning Commission
have |
|
| |
have to come more than once. After some discussion it was decided to
continue as |
|
| |
before with the entire packet presented at first hearing. |
|
| |
| |
The meeting was adjourned at 7:20pm. |
|
| |
| |
Lee Garner, Secretary |
|
| |
| |
LG:mvj |
|
| |
| |
**Next meeting August 12, 2002 at
6:00pm |
|
| |
Public Hearing Centennial Oaks Rezoning |
|
| |
Special Land Use, Elizabeth's Assisted Living |
|
| |
Pond Committee: Lammy, Gardner |
|
| |
Vilican-Leman Draft of Master Plan |
|